By Michael Ventresca
Recently I was asked why a very good quality company would use magnesium stearate in their product. The customer had heard that this was a potentially dangerous ‘filler’ and was surprised to find it on so many labels. (Magnesium stearate is often used as a lubricant during capsule filling and is also used as a binder in tablets to hold other ingredients together.)
Before I give you my opinion, I’d also like to share how surprised I was that within hours of this question, I received an email from Jarrow Formulas (included below) that discussed, in greater detail then I could ever hope to, this very subject! It seems some brands aren’t playing nice, and Jarrow Formulas may just take their quarrel to the Federal Trade Commission.
According to Jarrow, Ultra Laboratories has been suggesting that magnesium stearate is, for lack of a better word, bad. Because Jarrow (and countless other manufacturers) uses magnesium stearate,they felt it necessary to respond.
It has come to our attention that a supplement marketer, Ultra Laboratories, has been enclosing in their shipments a notice entitled “INGREDIENT WARNING, Stearic Acid/Magnesium Stearate.” The statement contains false and misleading statements regarding the compounds stearic acid and magnesium stearate. These statements create confusion among retailers and consumers and also result in damage to the reputation and business operations of many nutraceutical and pharmaceutical companies, including Jarrow Formulas, Inc.
As colleagues in the nutrition industry, we are disappointed by this type of unprofessional conduct. The statements in question are without scientific merit.
The publications Ultra Laboratories cite do not support their claim of potential toxicity of stearic acid and magnesium stearate. In fact, stearic acid is a normal part of the human diet.
But the email doesn’t end there -
The statements published by Ultra Laboratories are false, reckless, and damaging to the image of the dietary supplement industry as a responsible industry. It is misleading to consumers. We are demanding that Ultra laboratories cease and desist from their false, defamatory and misleading campaign or we will be compelled to take the matter to the proper division of the Federal Trade Commission and the National Advertising Division of the Better Business Bureau.
While I have not seen one of these notices, I do find a practice of making bold claims without supporting evidence disturbing (and so would my Philosophy 101 prof in College!).
Personally, the inclusion of magnesium stearate in my supplement is not a huge concern for me. This has been an issue for as long as I can remember, and the answers I’ve received from companies in the past are really no different than what Jarrow is saying today. Perhaps I put too much faith in these companies and the science they provide, but I believe them. For me, it’s a cost-benefit thing – like exercising.
When you exercise, your body generates free radicals. Now, most of the time we try to avoid free radicals, but in the case of exercise I think we’d all agree that for the most part, the benefits outweigh the costs. Whatever damage we do by exercising, is more than made up for by the positive benefits.
For me, the same is true with magnesium stearate. I feel I’ve chosen the products I take carefully, and believe they improve and enhance my health, regardless of the inclusion of magnesium stearate.
What I would like to know is why do some companies find it necessary to use magnesium stearate while others don’t? Is it related to cost? The raw material used?
By the way, for their part Jarrow did include quite a bit of supporting evidence to their assertion that magnesium stearate is safe included with the email I received. The complete email from Jarrow follows.
Continue reading False Information about Stearic Acid and Magnesium Stearate
